Make More Love and Peace
Posted: March 13, 2009 Filed under: Make Love and Peace 4 Comments »It’s kind of funny how reviews work. I like reading them after the fact, just to see what other people say about something I’ve already read, and I also read them to try and get a feel for series that I’m thinking of starting. I rarely read reviews for things I plan on reading before I get to whatever it is myself. I did so by chance before both volumes of this series, though, just because I’m extremely interested in what other people say about LuvLuv titles. Before the first volume, I read Julie’s positive review at Manga Maniac Cafe, and I wound up liking it okay, since I agreed with her that the characters liking each other was sort of different in the LuvLuv books. Before I read this volume, though, I read Ed’s impression at Mangacast, and he said it was one of the worst books of the year (well, that was in the Aurora report card). I don’t think it was that bad, but I could definitely see a lot of weaknesses in the characters and story while I was reading it.
Make of that what you will.
Regardless of any preconcieved notions I had going in, these stories focused a lot more on Ayame’s insecurities than they did the couple busting crime together. In fact, a lot of the story deals with a teen delinquent vying for Koichi herself and making Ayame doubt her feelings or Koichi’s feelings for her. A lot of this didn’t sit right… for instance, who in their right mind would assume their boyfriend, a police officer in his twenties, is going to immediately fall for a pushy delinquent teenager? One of the plot points hinged on the fact the teenager told Ayame that she was putting on a “good girl act” due to the death of her parents. This didn’t make much sense to me at all, and it deeply unhinged Ayame. I have no idea what was even going on there. Another plot point was the teenager suggesting that Koichi meant more to her than he did to Ayame, because given the choice to save Koichi or her parents from falling off a cliff, she would save Koichi. Since Ayame couldn’t decide who she would save (in that case, Koichi or her grandparents), she became very upset and began doubting her feelings. What?! Why would anyone ever think that based on a silly age-old question like that?
And each chapter sort of read like it had a moral at the end, followed by three pages of sex. I don’t know what happened to this series here.
The last third or so of the volume contains two unrelated stories. The first one, “Just Like a Romance Novel,” is about a librarian falling for a boy who isn’t normally her type. This was pretty standard fare, and I was kind of embarassed by the way she kept comparing what happened in her relationship to the plot of a romance novel. I work in a bookstore, and such metaphors don’t really dance through my mind while I’m going about my day, so I just couldn’t accept that it was something a librarian did.
The second story, “The Way You Look at Me,” was somewhat baffling. A woman begins dating a man, and before it gets serious, she reveals that she hides a scar she has over her eye with makeup. Apparently this is a big deal for all her other boyfriends, who immediately dumped her when they found out (?!), but she’s happy the new guy can accept her. She goes out on dates with the scar uncovered. Incredibly, random passerbys stop and stare, shocked and appalled by the scar on this woman’s face. It’s clear that her boyfriend isn’t enjoying his time out, the woman is insecure again, there is a twist, blah blah blah. This one was less good than it was puzzling.
Anyway. It’s probably safe to give this one a pass. Do pick up its predecessor, “Object of Desire,” which is a wonderful LuvLuv book.
Basara 21
Posted: March 13, 2009 Filed under: Basara 7 Comments »I had forgotten to mention this before, but I loved reading the essays in the backs of the volumes of this series. The books don’t have much in the way of footnotes, but we were treated to the pleasant and informative essays that helped explain any cultural mysteries that popped up. If I’m not mistaken, these were all written by Gerard Jones, who did the adaptation through volume 17. They are editor’s notes though, so the writer could also be Ian Robertson or P. Duffield. The editor for the series through those volumes, Patricia Duffield, wrote them. They are sorely missed once they stop appearing. Not that Basara is indecipherable without them, but they did add to my reading experience, at least.
I’m not sure if we got to see his face at the end of last volume, but I’m still impressed it took so long to unveil King Ukon. He’s actually sort of a lame villian, ruling more out of habit than with any vested interest in being a tyrant.
In this volume, Tatara and the Red King, now King of Japan, prepare to go to war with each other. I still have no idea what it is Shuri has in mind, but he manages to fire up everyone in Kyoto and get them all behind his war effort. He even gets most people to grudgingly hand over most or all of their wealth.
Also, I like that he is so happily taking a bath just before his war. As much as it confused me, the scenes where he was addressing the crowd in Kyoto were pretty amazing just because he really knows all the right things to say to get people to follow him. His kingly qualities show. But again… why the war after all this change he’s gone through? Will he really let a grudge against Tatara stand? But he says that she’s the only one he would ever consider marrying! Hmm. I flew through these volumes because I wanted to see the Sarasa/Shuri reunion SO BAD. They haven’t really been together since volume 15, but the reunion should be spectacular after all this time and character development.
Shima is still around, despite being soundly rejected by Shuri several times. I like that Shima is here, because it raises the possibility that perhaps the rift between Shuri and Sarasa is too big, which… you know, would be understandable given all the murdering and such. But her presence is puzzling since she isn’t really a threat to their relationship. Perhaps she just serves to show that Shuri still loves Sarasa… though what he wants to do with that love remains to be seen. Is love enough? Hmm.
The war starts off with some nice tricks traded between Shuri and Sarasa. Nothing heavy as of yet. Tatara kicks things off by basically telling Ginko off as a threat. I think she’s still a threat even without Tatara trusting her, but we’ll see.
And my mistake. Taro’s story wraps up in this volume with a message that both Shuri and Sarasa desperately need to get before they go too far into the attack. Apparently there is a bigger conspiracy afoot, though one wonders how it’s so big that it could unseat both a king and a resistance movement that’s captured the entirety of the country.
I was also quite pleased by Shuri’s elephants. What a fine thing to use in battle.
Oishinbo 2: Sake
Posted: March 13, 2009 Filed under: Oishinbo 7 Comments »Once again, in the interest of full disclosure, I am a total slob whose eating habits would make most people sick to their stomach. I am not the person who this series is aimed at, as I have no idea what is being discussed. Alcohol in particular is a big mystery to me, I almost never drink because I don’t like the taste. Oishinbo suggests I just haven’t tasted the good stuff though, which may be true.
Though the volume is called “sake,” a variety of alcoholic beverages are discussed. Admittedly, most others are discussed as a comparison to sake, but reading the volume will net you a great deal of knowledge about how wine is made, what makes it good, how the process between making wine and champagne differs, what foods go well with wine and what foods do not, and there are two different stories about turning people who snub sake, a very Japanese drink, in favor of wine.
If you take anything away from this book, know that apparently most mass produced sake (at least at the time the story was written) was made with volume in mind rather than quality, and things like sugar and alcohol are added into mass-produced brands to reduce the amount of rice needed to make it. Apparently this is a practice left over from the war when it was done out of necessity since there wasn’t enough rice… but since it’s very cheap, the tradition continues. According to the book, sake tastes better with no additives, and the point is made several times no false ingredients go into wine or any other high-class drink. Also, apparently bourbon is American, which I didn’t know.
One story takes up almost half the volume by itself, which strikes me as a bit unusual, though perhaps there are a lot of ongoing stories like this in the series itself. The story is about a small sake distillery that is about to be consumed by a larger commercial operation due to an outstanding debt. The story is about the characters convincing a bank to give the distillery the loan since they produce some of the finest sake in the country, sake is a cultural heritage, sake appreciation is on the rise, et cetera.
Oddly, the production of sake is never discussed in that much detail other than to describe how polishing off a certain percentage of the rice increases the quality the more the rice is polished. Also strange is the fact that most of the stories are about the characters standing up for sake, and only one is really about comparing different types of fine sake (the one with the literary agent). Brands and sake are compared in the other stories, but mostly it’s to discuss how the additives affect the flavor versus the pure sake made by the small outfits.
Again, if you’re looking for plot or deep characters, you’re not going to find it here. This series is fascinating because of the indepth look it gives different culinary subjects. As I said, I have no interest in fine food, but even I’m totally drawn into these books because it’s just interesting to read about this stuff. I imagine someone who is more of an epicure than I getting a lot more out of this book, so if you are at all inclined, I would invite you to check it out.
This was a review copy provided by Viz.
Basara 20
Posted: March 12, 2009 Filed under: Basara 15 Comments »This will be short.
Let’s see. In Kyoto, there is some sort of martial law in effect, and people are being slayed by the local police, the Yarogumi. The Yarogumi are only upholding the strict laws set up by the nobility, which are things like curfews and bans on different things. Apparently the higher-ups and other tyrants are slowly being eliminated by some sort of large, one-eyed ape. Of course, this one-eyed ape is working in the best interest of Tatara, so… it’s pretty clear what’s going on.
A lot of the focus of the volume is on Taro and his efforts to try and figure out what sort of conspiracy may have set up for Tatara and the Red King. He does this by traveling in the heart of the mountains to try and figure out what is being built in secret there. He is successful, but of course the conspirators are after him, and it become a race to get the information to Tatara.
Taro is a good character, though I don’t give him much thought. There are probably over 40 characters in this series, so some of them are going to be lost in the shuffle no matter how good they are. I sort of set him aside since he’s the self-declared observer, but he’s got his own role to play, and it’s sort of unfortunate where it leads him. I think I would have preferred him as a simple watcher, but he turns out to be just as much an ally to Tatara as anyone else in the end.
There’s also a lot about Asagi in this volume. He works with Ginko, who managed to make me feel more uncomfortable than Asagi. She sounds like she’s against King Ukon, despite being his daughter, but in her case, I think it’s safe to ask the question “Is the enemy of my enemy really my friend?” And… well, I didn’t think it could be done, but I like Asagi more and more between this volume and the last. I still can’t tell if he’s on Ginko’s side or Sarasa’s or his own, but he’s been playing nice with everyone lately, and everyone seems to really like him. It’s hard for me to believe he’s putting on an act when he’s in camp at this point, especially around Sarasa… though that’s certainly not out of the question.
There’s a battle against King Ukon’s army, a small but key one for Tatara. The best moment in the volume was probably when it was revealed that the battle would be won or lost based on whether or not Asagi took a leap of faith down a cliff. It’s really this scene, combined with the stuff about his feelings for Sarasa last volume, that make me think he… might not actually wish the Tatara camp bad luck.
Oh, Shuri. I just can’t tell what he’s thinking. One of his father’s most loyal advisors sought Shuri out to try and help the King against Tatara’s invasion of Kyoto. It’s clear that his opinions have shifted drastically since he spouts off the line “the same red blood flows in kings and slaves alike,” but on the other hand… he’s King now. King of Japan. Because… because he went back and decided that’s what he was going to do. I don’t know where this is going. I can’t tell what he’s thinking. It’s maddening.
Well, okay, not so short.
Classical Medley 2
Posted: March 12, 2009 Filed under: Classical Medley 1 Comment »I figured I’d just finish this story up with the second volume. It’s cute, but mostly good for kids. I don’t think a lot of teens or adults will be too into this one.
Everything set up in the first volume plays out pretty much exactly how you would imagine it. Soprano and Alto go into the neighboring kingdom to try and get help from Soprano’s brother, the elder prince of the Classical kingdom. The neighboring kingdom, Alla Marcia, is a place where toys come to life. The brainwashed members of the quintet come to take Soprano and Alto back to Classical, and they also try to get the “medley” from Alla Marcia as per the instructions of the evil overlord. Things happen just in time, there is an epic showdown, Soprano and Alto realize things about one another… you know how this stuff goes. You won’t find any surprises, but it’s still a nice story. The telling is quite energetic and the characters are likable, if shallow. I think the only thing that’s slightly less than kid friendly here is the gigantic breasts that the queen sports for no reason. No jokes are made, there is no innuendo, and they aren’t referenced at all. But they are there and they are very huge. They’re there on the cover, if you’re curious, and… is she wearing panties? Huh?
My favorite detail is that the two toys that highlight and explain the whole toy kingdom thing are Muscleman and Pandaman. Muscleman is the literal translation of Kinnikuman, a really popular Shounen Jump series from the 80s about wrestling. Kinnikuman’s opponents were always chosen from characters that kids would send in for that purpose. Pandaman was a character that young Eiichiro Oda submitted to the series. I don’t know that Pandaman ever actually made it into Kinnikuman, but he is a frequent background character in One Piece. Muscleman and Pandaman in this series look nothing like their (real-life? manga?) counterparts, but I like the connection all the same. Apparently they are still bitter rivals in the kingdom of Alla Marcia.
Fushigi Yugi: Genbu Kaiden 8
Posted: March 10, 2009 Filed under: Fushigi Yugi: Genbu Kaiden 1 Comment »I just… this makes me want to read the first series. I didn’t think that would ever happen. But… this is good, and the first series comes out in those big editions… maybe… maybe it’s time I gave it a second chance.
Yeah, I like this series a lot. I had trouble following the first half of this volume. Uruki is still recovering from what happened last volume, and actually, all the celestial warriors gather back together under the protection of a friendly rebel clan and a forest that forms a magical barrier against enemies. They’re all pretty critically injured, and after what happened at the end of last volume there also needs to be some closure. I actually like the way the event was dealt with, it was quite tasteful and stuck with the spirit of the series as far as… priestesses and magic and stuff go. I wasn’t really familiar with what was going on last volume, but this was touching all the same.
The second half of the volume is strategy as to how to recruit Teg and his brother, the final Celestial Warrior. This will be tricky since apparently they are both under the thumb of the emperor. They’re sort of hostile and sort of not in that shoujo-manga-enemies-that-are-supposed-to-be-friends kind of way. It’s handled much better in this series than it was in Fushigi Yugi, at least (except in FY, it was kind of backwards, if I remember right). I mean, it is kind of transparent, and it’s pretty obvious that Teg is a good guy at heart, but the conflict of interest is better at keeping him on the other side.
And a fairly obvious plot development happens at the end where everyone pretends to hate the priestess so she’ll go away. I suspect it’s because her death has been foretold, but that is left for the next volume. I can see it coming a mile away, but I still want to read it badly.
I actually like this a lot, and this is even with all the stuff I don’t understand about the character backstories and political climate. While I do want to read the beginning of this series, I’m actually more set on Fushigi Yugi at this point. I know it’s much shallower than the fantasy I’ve been favoring lately, but it’s still really girly manga, and maybe I’ll like it better than I did when I was reading it all those years ago. It’s a classic, and I suspect it’s a lot closer to Genbu Kaiden quality-wise than I’m remembering. At the very least, reading FY in a big edition will help me weather the wait for new volumes of this, new volumes only seem to come out twice a year in Japan and the US version is one volume away from catching up.
This was a review copy provided by Viz.
Honey Hunt 1
Posted: March 9, 2009 Filed under: Honey Hunt 6 Comments »I’m not going to lie to you. I’m super-excited about this series. I loved Hot Gimmick. But, you know, I always had this suspicion I would like it a little less if I reread it, because I know it’s trashy and I don’t think I quite realized it at the time. This one confirmed my suspicions.
Guys. This series is VICIOUS. In the first chapter, we find out the main character, Yura, is the daughter of a famous actress and a world-renowned musician. She is largely ignored and neglected at home while her parents go on TV and talk about what good parents they are. Her only friend is her tutor and next door neighbor. One night, her mother comes home, reveals to her that she needed to leave the house that night because her father was caught in the middle of an affair and they were going to get a divorce and sell the house. She is given free reign to do whatever she wants. The girl DOES NOT want this, especially since she heard nothing about it beforehand, and hadn’t actually seen either of her parents in two weeks.
Nobody seems to care about her as she is ushered off to a hotel room ahead of the paparazzi. Her tutor sends her a message asking about her well-being, though. She sneaks back into her house to see him… only to find him and her mother together.
Her mother tells her she’s sorry that the boy likes her better than her daughter. WHAT.
Things sort of go downhill from there. Her mother’s manager quits and decides to guide Yura into an acting career that she’s going to use to dominate and humiliate her mother. Sort of like Skip Beat, I guess. Except it’s not as good as Skip Beat, because Koyoko has a backbone and a real drive to succeed, whereas Yura just sort of… seems to luck into her parts by occasionally being friendly. At least, so far.
Also, not only does her mother’s manager have some sort of ambiguous, possibly work-related attraction, so do both of the hot celebrities. Who are twins. One proposes to her.
Guys, this is pretty trashy stuff, but I’m going to eat it up with a spoon. There’s something irresistible and addictive about this, because despite all this stuff, I LOVED IT. This is the absolute dictionary definition of a guilty pleasure. I can’t wait to see what ridiculousness will come after this.
This was a review copy provided by Viz.
Basara 19
Posted: March 9, 2009 Filed under: Basara 13 Comments »This and volume 20 are insanely hard to come by for some reason. I acquired both of them after searching for about a month or so, but rituals were performed. Lives were lost. Amazon was checked daily for a sanely-priced copy.
The black holes that form in the middle of Viz series are a bit mysterious. Why are there shortages of volumes 19 and 20? Why not the first volumes? Did the print run suddenly decrease at this point? And if so, why are 18 and 21 still easy to come by? It is a mystery.
Until you read this volume and realize that people are probably hoarding it for the Asagi scene alone.
I’ve never read a series like this that so successfully balances an epic war spanning an entire country with a really nice romance. I’ve said before that I enjoy stories that take advantage of their setting, specifically in relation to novels that are about trips across America, and Basara is great for that, too. I know nothing about the geography of Japan, so the details are lost on me, but I can certainly see how much work was put into having Sarasa travel to every region and look at what makes each area unique. Of course, some of those details might only exist in Basara, and I couldn’t tell you which ones (except for the whole desert thing), but I can appreciate the fact they’re there, and it makes the story that much more ambitious.
Lots and lots and lots of stuff happens in this volume. I think it might be my favorite so far, even after all that stuff that happened in 14 and 15. Tatara and her accumulated Navy take on King Ukon’s navy, and an epic sea battle is had on board the Phoenix, one that includes dolphins that have bombs strapped to them and are somehow trained to run into the boats. After this happens, a group of assassins drop onto the ship and engage all the major characters in battle. In any other volume, the assassins engaging every single one of the major allies would have been the highlight, but the fact that it’s overshadowed by everything else here should tell you just how AWESOME volume 19 really is.
After this battle, there is… well, like, the ultimate scene between Asagi and Sarasa. I can never tell if Asagi is coming or going, and its apparent he’s a little confused himself when it comes to Sarasa. He offers to kill her as a mercy, says he’s going to kill her anyway, wants to ally with her, wants to run away with her, wants her to stay by his side. It was just awesome. He’s also insanely jealous about everything a person could be jealous of, I think.
Later, Tatara and a small entourage go to meet with the former Black King’s army, led by Shuri. The army is engaged in a battle, and as they approach, without anyone saying anything out loud, Asagi says something to the effect of “Idiots are usually at the front of the battle.” Aww. But a reunion is not to be.
There is an indirect kiss. I died a little inside. It’s so corny in any other series, but the fact that three characters are in on it, along with Sarasa’s facial expressions while she’s riding off, make Basara the only series that uses this technique that I cannot make fun of.
And volume 20 was even harder to get. What does that have in it? A reunion? Please?
Saint Seiya 16
Posted: March 9, 2009 Filed under: Knights of the Zodiac 1 Comment »While I had some sort of moral quandary about whether to call a series LoveCom or Lovely Complex, I have no problem calling this one by its Japanese name, which is entirely unrelated to the English title. I don’t know why it doesn’t give me pause. It probably should.
I’m told that the series gets better again after the Poseidon Saga, and I just need to power through this part, which is not very long. I mean… it’s got all the stuff that makes the series awesome, like characters being killed and miraculously coming back to life, characters being blinded, characters dealing the “final blow” again and again and again as they try to outmatch each other, and lots of marveling over each other’s cosmo. If you don’t like this stuff, you probably don’t like Saint Seiya.
But I feel like these talents could be applied in better ways than fighting the Poseidon Knights. Though Lymnades does manage to lay everyone out. That was actually quite impressive. I also got a ridiculous kick out of the part where he begins to fool Ikki again. I have no idea why the story went through all the motions just to fool the reader. I wish more manga did that.
Do Whatever You Want 7
Posted: March 9, 2009 Filed under: Do Whatever You Want Leave a comment »I reviewed this for the Manga Minis column at Manga Recon, so you can check it out over there. It’s… it’s worth reading, I liked it, and I was fascinated by the relationship juggling and the fact that, should you choose, you can imagine the main character with either a guy or a girl in the end. This inevitably means that no decision is reached in the end, which is of course never a good thing.
But, you know, Boy Bands. I had to have N’Sync and Backstreet Boys playing while I wrote the review to get me in the mood.
Also, Hosoo is reading Hotel Africa in one of the bonus stories at the end. See, it’s so good that even other manga/manhwa characters read it.