Shugo Chara! 6
Posted: July 21, 2009 Filed under: Shugo Chara! Leave a comment »Peach-Pit – Del Rey – 2009 – 9+ volumes
I reviewed this for the weekly Manga Minis column at Manga Recon, so check out the review over there.
I don’t really have much else to say about it, other than it has been awhile since I’ve read a magical girl series, and I should probably fix that sometime soon by starting one from the beginning. I have to be in the mood though, otherwise I won’t enjoy it. They are, by their very nature, sort of shallow fun, and if I don’t hit them at the right time, I’ll only see the shallow.
Jyu-Oh-Sei 2
Posted: July 19, 2009 Filed under: Jyu-Oh-Sei 2 Comments »Natsumi Itsuki – Tokyopop – 2009 – 3 volumes
Like Fruits Basket, I waited to read the second volume of this until I had the third. Unlike Fruits Basket, I then waited some time before reading it, which is a shame, because this is a wonderful series. It reminds me a lot of To Terra… and Andromeda Stories in spirit, but I like Jyu-Oh-Sei a lot better than those two series.
I really like this series for its somewhat desperate, fatalistic fantasy setting. I like any manga series with a well-realized, non-generic fantasy world, really, and there are so few good examples in the US that aren’t total fanservice. On one hand, it’s kind of ridiculous at the beginning of the book when Thor seems to be besting a group of adolescents and people in their 20s at the age of 11, but on the other hand, I like that a mix of luck and Third cheating for him get him his place. His luck and destiny in becoming the Beast King are emphasized more and more as the volume continues, and I simultaneously love and hate the fact that Thor isn’t really master of his own destiny, but is being controlled almost entirely by Third and later Zagi. He seems to have little mind of his own aside from a survival instinct and a desperate need to get off the planet (a prize awarded only to the Beast King).
I also still really enjoy the fully realized social structure present on Kimaera. This was mostly established last volume, and it’s one of the more fascinating things about the series, because of its simplicity, the way it works with the weather patterns on the planet, the fact that the discrepencies between Thor’s colony upbringing and the native residents of Kimaera keep coming up, and because crashing this social struture will bring the Colony government running, for some reason. The government’s interest in and the secrets surrounding Kimaera are a little less well-realized, but that will probably come next time, since we get two rather huge bombshells at the end of the volume here.
The shoujo elements are floating around, adding a soft touch to everything. Rai’s death still haunts Thor, and at this point, I’m less sure that Rai will come back unharmed. I was sure that was going to happen at one point towards the end of the volume, but the vicious ecosystem of the planet won out over my hopes (yet another really awesome detail, simple but very important). Thor is also shaken by the reappearance of Zagi, by the fact that the entire planet’s social system is crashing down around him, and by love, as any good shoujo hero should be. The situation between he and Tiz is a sad one, and a new contender joins the fight for Thor’s heart, though Thor is still thoroughly shaken by the “mating rituals” of Kimaera, and tries to explain his feelings yet again to Tiz and the new girl.
The outside government will factor into the next volume and the ending, so I’m looking forward to how that will be integrated into the rich plot and setting of the series. I’m very much looking forward to it.
Fruits Basket 23
Posted: July 19, 2009 Filed under: Fruits Basket 6 Comments »Natsuki Takaya – Tokyopop – 2009 – 23 volumes
Despite my crusty, bitter opinions to the contrary in the last post, the thing I like most in this series is that each of the 25 characters has a bit of personality. I still think that’s way too many, and I would have enjoyed the series a lot more had the numbers been pared down, but the fact that a joke from Ritsu, a character that literally hasn’t appeared since his introduction, made me laugh in this volume says a lot about the sense of humor and the writing behind the characters. The jokes from Uotani and Hanajima always make me laugh, and there’s a few good ones in this volume for the road.
My prediction from last time was mostly correct though, in that I wasn’t too terribly interested in the loose ends here. Most of what goes on is exactly what I imagined happening, except here I don’t get a lot of satisfaction in seeing the characters go through the motions as I did with the Kyo and Tohru scene in last volume.
This volume also has a good example of another thing about this series I kind of don’t like. The event that is somewhat significant, and can be happy, or sad, I guess, but is blown horribly out of proportion by everyone involved in a way that causes a failure to connect on my part. Kyo and Tohru go traveling, and there are scenes and scenes and scenes of everyone in the series tearing up because they are going to leave town. I just… didn’t understand. Maybe I just wasn’t as into it as I should have been, though.
For the record, I thought it was super-creepy to end the regular storyline on Tohru’s mother like that. I know that it was supposed to be inspirational in its way, but it was horribly depressing, and those last two pages just didn’t erase the rest of that long scene from my memory. Alas, not a good way to leave things.
But here you are, the end of Fruits Basket. I said most of what I wanted to about the series in the last review, so I’ll just leave it at that. I’m sorry, Fruits Basket, I think you’re just not for me.
Also, why Fruits Basket and not Fruit Basket? I don’t care what the original title was, something that simple not getting fixed BUGS ME TO NO END. Maybe that’s the real reason why I couldn’t get into it.
One last thing, too, because I have a hard time shutting up: You remember those zodiac profiles that the volumes had in them when the zodiac characters were featured on the cover, so Shigure’s volume had the Year of the Dog profile in the back? I seem to remember that starting after the Yuki cover. Did… did the Year of the Rat profile ever appear in another volume? I don’t think it did. Maybe volume 2 is just reprinted with that in it (which would make sense). Or maybe people born in the Year of the Rat are just doomed to never know their Fruits Basket fortune now. Alas. I’m wrong about this, there was a Year of the Rat profile in volume 2. I apparently just slept through it. Thank you, Badtzphoto!
Fruits Basket 22
Posted: July 19, 2009 Filed under: Fruits Basket 3 Comments »Natsuki Takaya – Tokyopop – 2009 – 23 volumes
I waited to read this until I had the final volume. I kind of wish I hadn’t, because everything I was looking forward to was in this volume. It ends in a really good place, and I find I’m not very curious about the lives of the characters after this, or how Akito is going to live with himself or whatever. Everything just ends here, and now I’m not really looking forward to the final volume.
Though I’ve been pretty caught up by the ending the past few volumes, and I tend to be pretty positive when I write these reviews, I’m still not all that fond of Fruits Basket. I was reflecting on the series after I finished this volume, and it’s kinda… I don’t know. A dozen characters who are depressed because they are cursed to turn into animals when people hug them? A horrible, dark core to the series based on the head of their family, driven by… selfishness? Cursed with selfishness? Nobody else can love them, because they’re cursed to be loved only by Akito, who abuses them instead? The dark past and the bad blood between Akito and his mother is because… they fought over who Akito’s dad loved more? I guess as the series got more and more serious, it was kind of easy to forget that the horrible, ostracizing curse that everyone always talked about was to turn into a cute animal (except in Kyo’s case). And as engrossing as some of the stories were, I frequently found that I wasn’t terribly interested in the sadness of side characters. Even though I probably was when I was reading the story, which is proof that the writing style is at the very least addictive. I think I would have liked it better had there been less characters, but the fact that the emotional trauma was spread out over 25 or so characters made things far less interesting and believable for me in the end.
Again, I realize I’m saying this after a slew of positive reviews for the later volumes of the series, and I’m about to talk about how much I liked this volume. But it’s more or less how I’ve always felt about the series.
This volume pretty much wraps everything up. Everything about the curse, a lot of things about the relationships between all the characters, but especially everything for Kyo. He speaks to his dad, and then has to take care of this business with Tohru.
The scene between Kyo and Tohru is just about perfect. The whole series led up to it, and it does everything you would expect. Everything, everything, everything. And it’s wonderful.
And that’s why everyone loves Fruits Basket, I think.
Disappearance Diary
Posted: July 17, 2009 Filed under: Disappearance Diary 7 Comments »Hideo Azuma – Fanfare – 2008 – one-shot
Strangely, I think the last two books I picked up from Fanfare were autobiographical works by famous/notable mangaka unknown in America that related horrible/tragic personal stories in a detached and lighthearted way. Fanfare may actually have a monopoly on this genre, because it seems that no other publisher has released a book that approach anything like Disappearance Diary or Doing Time.
In Doing Time’s case, it was Kazuichi Hanawa’s story of being in prison after being caught with a gun model that was too realistic. Rather than talking about what he did to get there or injustice or the usual prison topics, it is an oddly impersonal account that simply catalogs day-to-day prison life in extreme, extreme detail, down to diagrams of the meals on the plates. Hanawa might not actually be as famous as I think he is, or like to think he is. He’s one of the Garo artists (and a fantastic artist, at that), and I enjoyed his story Mercy Flesh in Comics Underground Japan immensely, but I’m not sure how much of an impact he’s had elsewhere. On the other hand, I know I’ve read at least three different accounts of his legal problems in different books I have, so he must be of some interest.
Hideo Azuma, on the other hand, is the father of lolicon, for better or worse, and Disappearance Diary is a comical, detached story about two different times he snapped under deadline pressure and decided to live as a homeless man for as long as a year, and then later about his recovery from alcoholism. He states right off the bat that the book will have a positive outlook, so he’s going to remove as much of the gloomy stuff from the story as possible. He also does this because he says it’s hard to draw realistically, so this depressing, tragic story is drawn in a comical way that would make it look right at home next to Dilbert.
It’s actually pretty amazing how appealing he makes living homeless seem. He talks about how easy it was for him to get certain types of food certain places, and always makes the decision to show moments of triumph, like the day he found a convenience store that provided him so much food from its trash he was overweight when they finally found him and brought him home. He talks about his daily scavenges for cigarette butts, strange encounters with people and homeless people more crazy or agressive than him, how he hated being called a beggar (he got all his food from the trash, and didn’t beg money from people), and things like what eating radishes did to his digestion. All the stories are kind of funny and happy in their way, and the book is formatted in short chapters so that the day he finds the full bottle of whiskey, how great that is, and how he rations it and enjoys it with a proper meal takes up one short chapter.
The first bout of homelessness ends when he is picked up as a suspect for a crime and someone recognizes his name as a manga artist. The second round goes on until he gets bored of being homeless and is set up in construction/demolition job by a pair of shady brothers. This part of the book was also quite charming, because the shifty brothers and his cranky coworkers make for great gag characters, even if what they were doing wasn’t all that funny in real life.
Strangely, after this there’s a brief segment where he details his career as a manga artist and goes from his beginnings to his periods of semi-popularity and overwork that drove him to flee his career, and then flee it again. Apparently his wife was his only assistant for a long time, and also helped him come up with a lot of ideas and was the one that filed missing persons reports on him and had him committed for his alcoholism. It never mentions anything much about her, but if he stayed married to the same woman throughout his entire life and career, she is truly a saint. He may acknowledge this strain at one point by not detailing their reunion after a disappearance, because “there wasn’t anything funny about it.”
That section reads a little like a deranged, short version of A Drifting Life, except for sci-fi romantic comedy and lolicon instead of gekiga. I laughed really hard at a panel where Azuma and a few other artists rally for the cause of trying to stop the yaoi takeover at comiket with their new (and presumably the first) lolicon book. Also notable is that most of his work was for Akita Shoten, my favorite Japanese publisher, and even more notable is the fact that many of his stories ran in the completely insane Shounen Champion magazine and its spinoffs, perhaps proving that jolly poor taste (which I mean as a compliment) has always been the aim of that publication.
And because he’s writing about the history of manga, even if it’s just a little bit, he talks about how he met with Osamu Tezuka, and we learn that apparently editors were constantly changing Tezuka’s stuff. Which… I mean, I’ve read his stories, and they are quite literally the most rambling and insane stories you can find. What did they look like before the editors got to them?
The final part of the book talks about how he later became an alcoholic, and even this part has a light touch even though there’s nothing funny about it. He talks about how he needed to drink in order to fall asleep, but drinking enough for that left him feeling too sick to drink the next day, and he would start to hallucinate and become suicidal. Eventually he started passing out in random places and was too inebriated to draw, which is when his wife had him committed against his will to a psychiatric hospital, where he recovered. Interestingly, the AA program seems to be about the same in Japan with the same types of practices at the meetings, ways of addressing members, and even the same serenity prayer.
And speaking of rambling and insane, I’m going to go ahead and stop talking now. In short: Disappearance Diary is an extremely interesting book not only because of its story, but because it manages to keep a light touch and a lot of humor in what would otherwise be an incredibly depressing story (for a shocking shot of realism at the end, he states in an interview in the back that during his bouts of homelessness he was so cold he thought he was going to die). It’s an interesting story, but because of its nature a lot of details are left out, and the timeline between episodes isn’t clear. If you think it sounds interesting, you’ll probably like it, but it’s not going to be something that appeals to a casual reader.
Black Lagoon 7
Posted: July 17, 2009 Filed under: Black Lagoon 3 Comments »Rei Hiroe – Viz – 2009 – 9+ volumes
The crazy maid arc continues with lots and lots and lots of exposition. Her family came to town looking for her, and she came to town to blow up what appears to be some form of the US Government. Because getting America involved in Roanapur would be very bad, there are people that want to stop her. There are also people that want her dead very badly. And there are people that want to stop anything at all from going down. So a lot of the bosses are called together to try and figure out what the intentions are around town.
Meanwhile, for some reason, Rock is called in by the head of the Triad to assist the maid’s family in finding her. I have no idea what Rock’s special power is here besides speaking civilly and getting Revy to both act nice and stand up for him, but he’s running around trying to fix things, with everyone telling him he’s nuts.
There’s an amazing, loaded scene between Rock and Revy at the end of the volume. Not really romantic, just incredibly loaded. I’ve only read three volumes of this series, but I wasn’t sure what was going to happen, but I knew the series would turn on it if it did. It was pretty awesome, and subtle in a way I wouldn’t have expected. Very nice.
I’ve got a pretty good handle on the way the series works and who the characters are and their roles, and I’m still not entirely convinced this isn’t more than a couple notches above average, but maybe that’s just because there was no action in this volume. With this much exposition, I would expect there to be lots of violence and action in all the right doses (read: like, ridiculously high) next volume.
This was a review copy provided by Viz.
Me & the Devil Blues 2
Posted: July 15, 2009 Filed under: Me & the Devil Blues 1 Comment »Akira Hiramoto – Del Rey – 2009 – 2+ volumes
This series is AMAZING. The second volume was not quite as gripping as the first, but it would be hard to top the section in the first volume where reality unhinges in the bar and then snaps back in place to reveal that R.J. has been missing for months. This volume was more plot-driven that the last one as well, and it moves at a pretty slow pace, but it’s still easy to appreciate everything that’s going on.
The slow pace is due in part to the way the series has of stalling on really tense scenes. There’s a few good ones with Clyde where he’s waiting out a blind man’s rage, or trying to figure out what’s going on in a room full of candy, or just napping on a porch. Some of these are more interesting than others, and the action scenes have a similar way of stretching themselves out for dramatic effect. The scene where R.J. and Clyde are being chased by hellhounds at the end of the volume is the best example, where the scene with Clyde breaking into the sheriff’s office is probably an example of a scene which lasted a bit too long. In all cases, the art really carries the day. This series gets away with a lot of things I wouldn’t stand for elsewhere simply because it looks really, really good doing it.
I was a bit disappointed that music played absolutely no part in this volume. I was even more disappointed when R.J. got his hands on a guitar at the end and was getting ready to play on the very last page… especially since I think the series has pretty much stopped and we’ll never see any more of it.
This is also disappointing because the plot built pretty slowly throughout this gigantic volume and was just beginning to pay off towards the end. The beginning is actually maddeningly slow, because Clyde is investigating the blind man that runs the town and R.J. is in prison awaiting death. Aside from the men that get thrown in with him and a chat with Ike, very little happens for him until later, though the talk with Ike is significant since Ike raises the issue of R.J.’s desires and what they ultimately cost him, whose fault his current situation is, and even a significant discussion on race relations.
There’s also an annoying loose thread about the ultimate fate of a little boy that the blind man keeps close to him. Clyde has trouble trying to figure out if he’d be able to save both the little boy and R.J., then decides to save R.J. when he goes to meet the little boy’s family. I’m not sure how a bad home life changed his mind, or if it did, or if they completely disregarded this problem (they may have, given how events turn out). I’m curious to see whether or not the blind man catches them in the end. The ruthless dogs are apparently also still after them, which was one of the most… I don’t know, outrageous chase scenes I’ve ever seen, including the totally badass way R.J. takes one of them out (which didn’t make me feel as bad as it sounds like it should have, since these are literally monster-dogs).
It may sound like I’m complaining a lot, but mostly I’m cranky because I’m pretty sure no more of this series will ever come out and I’m disappointed that it left off on such a cliffhanger. It’s an awesome series though, and both of the 600-page volumes are well worth picking up. They are by far the nicest thing that Del Rey has thus far published, which is saying a lot since I’m also quite fond of Faust and things like Parasyte.
Fairy Tail 6
Posted: July 15, 2009 Filed under: Fairy Tail 1 Comment »Hiro Mashima – Del Rey – 2009 – 14+ volumes
I figured I ought to read this volume since volume 7 arrived in the mail today. I like this series a lot, but I just can’t seem to convince myself to read the volumes as they come.
This volume was mostly the resolution to the Deliora story. All the actual fights go down exactly as you would imagine, except for the ultimate fate of Deliora (which was unexpected as well as hilarious) and the fact that “lost magic” was introduced, Natsu’s magic apparently falling in that category. Admittedly, I wasn’t all that interested in this story arc, save for the weird village that turns into creatures because of the moon drop ceremony.
The resolution to the villager’s problems was actually worth sitting through that long Deliora story for. Their actual problem was completely different than what it seemed, and I liked pretty much everything about their situation from beginning to end.
Afterwards, the main characters go back to Fairy Tail to accept their punishment and find it vandalized by a rival guild. They take the insults to avoid starting a horrible war until their members are mercilessly attacked by more powerful wizards, and then the entirety of Fairy Tail shows up at the other guild to basically assault them. This part is pretty cool, but unfortunately I’m not all that fond of the “conspiracy” direction that the plot seems to be heading (ie more powerful wizards orchestrated the attack using the rival guild in order to capture/provoke some of the wizards of Fairy Tail).
I do like this story better than the Deliora one so far, though, so I’m a bit more eager to read the next volume.
O-Parts Hunter 17
Posted: July 15, 2009 Filed under: O-Parts Hunter 1 Comment »Seishi Kishimoto – Viz – 2009 – 19 volumes total
This is another series that I’m pretty sure I’ve got mostly figured out. This volume was kind in that regard, and also a good volume in general since several groups of main characters were stuck in a kind of puzzle-y maze that took different strategies and most of the volume to navigate. A big chunk towards the end was spent on a fight between twin brothers, and I suspect that the next volume will have similar fights as each of the other three groups reach the end of their obstacle course. Apparently they are inside the enemy base, more or less, so I think they are very close to accomplishing what they set out to do.
Jio does very little in this volume, and his section of the maze consists of logic puzzles that are mostly solved by his teammate. Another part of the maze are music puzzles with Ball and… an older, powerful person and the adorable Jojomaru, the group with Ruby has to run a gauntlet of Indiana Jones-type traps, and Kirin’s group… uh, makes faces. Which is a little cooler than it sounds.
Kirin is the one fighting his brother at the end, and this fight takes awhile as it explains the family backstory and the brother’s inferiority complex et cetera. These parts were okay, even without me knowing much about Kirin. He doesn’t ever show his eyes, and the reason why is revealed here.
A lot of the Kaballah stuff is glossed over here, and I’m getting to like the series more and more for its quirky sense of humor and because of the whole O.P.T. thing. I’m thinking about going back for some of the early volumes at this point, but I’ll probably read to the end before that happens.
This was a review copy provided by Viz.
Swallowing the Earth
Posted: July 14, 2009 Filed under: Swallowing the Earth 3 Comments »Osamu Tezuka – Digital Manga Publishing – 2009 – 1 volume
I reviewed this Tezuka omnibus for Manga Recon, so you can check out the lengthy, in-depth review over there.
In short, I liked it. I liked it a lot. It’s got a lot to it, and is something of a cross between a story that you would find in Phoenix, with its serious and rambling themes, and something like MW and Ode to Kirihito, which pares the themes down and puts them in a more entertaining story (not to knock Phoenix too badly, but those two are a little more fun to read, at least for me). The themes aren’t nearly as heavy-handed here as they are in some of his other works. The thing about Swallowing the Earth, however, is that it hides its serious nature in what can only be described as insane details. Not often very important things, but all the same, details where you have to sit and stare for a minute, and then move on because you will never be able to comprehend why. The plot kind of rambles to places you don’t think it will go as a result, and towards the end, I was begging the story to narrow its focus so I could understand where the story was going to end up. It did make sense, and was a pretty awesome resolution, but the way it got there still has me scratching my head.
I love that sort of thing, especially since you would never see something like this today because an editor would get to it first, but all the same, there’s a reason that nobody but Tezuka can write stories like this. There’s a fine balance that it walks between sense and nonsense. Again, I love seeing stories that push the limits like this, but I can imagine it not really being to a lot of other people’s taste.
I also feel the need to reiterate my love for Gohanmatsu. I talk about him a lot in the regular review, but he really was a great main character. I loved that a story about the downfall of humanity featured a hero that was drunk and didn’t care, but somehow still loveable.
And because I have a fierce love for Tezuka’s Star System, let me talk about it here. My friends Lamp and Hamegg both appear, which is normally all I ask of a volume of Tezuka manga. True to form, Lamp is the evil bad guy that is the cause of all the madness, in a sense (he’s basically a jerk to his wife and daughters, causing them to flee to a South Pacific island and engineer the downfall of man). He’s also working with the Nazis again here, something else that just seems to suit his evil role. Hamegg, also true to form, appears briefly at the end of the story as something of an apologetic, cowardly thief. Duke Red appears briefly as… I don’t quite remember, a guy in charge of repossessing a character’s stuff, or something, which also suits his “bad guy but in a sympathetic sense” role. And Zephyrus, the girl that’s so beautiful she drives men mad, looks a lot like the “Black Queen” doctor that’s appeared in a pair of Black Jack stories. It’s possible they are not supposed to be the same “person,” but both characters have a beehive-looking hairdo that you just don’t see to often, so I’m going to go ahead and say that they are. James Moar helped me out with this in the comments, they are the same person and “Zephyrus” is what the character goes by. Thanks!
In case you were curious, the title comes from Gohanmatsu telling Zephyrus when they first meet that he’d like to drink enough alcohol to feel like he’s swallowing the earth. The title sticks when Zephyrus’ plans do just that in the end.