Cipher 5

Minako Narita – CMX – 2006 – 11 volumes

Wow, I love the subtle touch this series has.  Jake has been completely mute all this time that Roy and Anise have been getting close.  We were given hints towards the fact there was something wrong, but never, ever anything solid.  A new character in this volume cracks his character wide open, not only in the present, but also leads into a long flashback about the twins, so we can finally learn about the circumstances leading up to their lifestyle.

I accidentally started reading volume 6 before this one, and I initially didn’t like Dana.  I love the closeness between Roy, Jake, and Anise, and I hated the thought of someone else splitting the three of them apart, even Roy and Jake.  But Dana’s not like that.  Dana is someone for Jake to reach out to and let his feelings out.  Someone that he doesn’t feel responsible for, and really, a love interest, which is important if this series isn’t going to run off into twincest territory (and I give it a lot more credit than that, even with all the weird, but somehow still sentimental and not creepy, smooching those two do).  Jake feels comfortable at Dana’s house in a way that isn’t possible where he lives, and he winds up opening up to Roy and Anise a little more as a result, too.

Dana dabbles in performance, and it turns out she has a role with “Siva” in their next job.  Basically, Roy is doing the job and the two have to lie to Dana about their identity, which she doesn’t notice but her mother does.  When her mother threatens Jake, that’s when he opens up about his life story that we get to hear.

I don’t have that much to say about the life story.  It’s interesting in that it makes the fact they grew up as actors seem completely unglamorous.  That part is downplayed quite a bit, but the relationship between and with their parents isn’t.  There’s a lot that goes unspoken, and throughout the flashback, you can see Jake feeling more and more uncomfortable with his role as the “adult” of the twins where Roy gets all the attention for being the more flashy brother.  I love that the interpretation of most scenes is left up to the reader.  It’s not rocket science or anything, but I adore it when there’s not an inner monologue or narration ruining flashbacks like this.  I can think what I want, and his reactions help reinforce or change my opinions accordingly.

There’s also a really elaborate Thanksgiving scene in this volume.  Again, I’ve only read a handful of manga set in America, but none peg it as accurately as this.  This is the only instance of Thanksgiving I think I’ve ever seen, and it really is portrayed simply as a family meal and a simple holiday with a parade to celebrate.  I only wish we still had Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man floats in our Thanksgiving Day parades.  Also making a random appearance: The Pet Shop Boys.  They appear in a side bar, but one of the chapters is also called “East End Boys and a West End Girl.”

It’s still wonderfully sentimental and subtle, and more a drama of the twins than it is a romance or anything like that.  A bizarre shoujo coming-of-age story featuring twin boys rather than a central heroine.  In fact, Anise wasn’t in this volume at all.  Maybe she’ll be back more next time, but it sounds like the story moves away from her.  I’m interested to see where it goes, if it’s not a romance between Roy and Anise.


7 Comments on “Cipher 5”

  1. Estara says:

    Yay, Cipher! Vastly underrated probably due to its timeframe and art, I think. I thought it strengthens as it goes along, and not it’s not mainly the story of Anise and Roy – which I was also surprised about, but accepted happily at the end.

    If you enjoy this to the end, try the scanlations of Alexandrite, which have characters from this manga – also set in the US.

  2. Connie says:

    Ooh, nice! I didn’t realize there was a sequel, I think I might check it out when I finish up.

    I do like that the plot doesn’t follow the usual shoujo trends. While I’d like for Anise to return, I do love the focus being on the boys. And I can’t get enough of the radical 80s artwork, it’s a shame it doesn’t appeal to more people.

  3. Moon in Autumn says:

    I agree. I think CMX should really be rewarded for publishing solid, older series like this that are wonderful and full of unexpected twists all the way through to the end. I hope more people read it, love it, and buy it (and have better luck keeping the names straight)!

  4. [...] Flowers (Slightly Biased Manga) Tangognat on vol. 2 of Butterflies, Flowers (Tangognat) Connie on vol. 5 of Cipher (Slightly Biased Manga) Susan S. on Croquis (Manga Jouhou) Kristin on vol. 1 of Crown of Love [...]

  5. Estara says:

    There’ll be a return of Anise, but she definitely is not the focus of the story, which I also hadn’t expected when I started with Cipher.

    I totally agree with your comment on the artwork. That’s why I’m still very thankful for the scanlators that concentrate on scanlating classics.

  6. Connie says:

    Estara: It’s true. There’s a lot of stuff, like anything by Minako Narita or Reiko Shimizu, that I’m happy to see people take the time and translate since I’m sure they will never, ever come out here. Part of me still feels bad, because sometimes I’ll read a series like Crystal Dragon and secretly think it has a chance in English, even though I know there’s absolutely no way.

    Actually, it’s almost always series published by CMX that make me want to go back and look at what else they did (possibly because if it was released by Viz, I know more work will be coming soon). It’s a shame CMX can’t release more of that.

  7. Connie says:

    Moon in Autumn: I had such a hard time keeping the names straight that I had to memorize the story intro in the front of the volume, and whenever anyone used one of the names, I had to repeat the first line …Siva (Jake) and Cipher (Roy)… back to myself. Over and over again. I’m bad at remembering character names in general, though, even when it isn’t a set of twins with four names between them. Usually I have to keep a volume next to me when I write reviews of anything for that reason.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 385 other followers