Under Grand Hotel 1

March 9, 2011

Mika Sadahiro – 801 Media – 2010 – 2 volumes

Since I’ve talked about a macho male fantasy world completely divorced from reality, how about continuing the abuse train tonight with this, a series full of sex and female fantasies in a realm completely divorced from reality?

While I knew that one of my most hated BL plot devices was going to come up here (the premise is that it’s a BL romance set in a prison, so duh), I wasn’t expecting the level of brutality that was on display in the first chapter. Sen is raped with a broom handle by a man who was pretending to protect him from a violent gang. From there, we meet Sword Fish (first name Sword, last name Fish), the violent and temperamental “boss” of the prison inmates who initially keeps Sen as his “bitch” because Sen doesn’t like it, then the two of them fall passionately in love.

I wouldn’t have picked this up save for the fact I read several reviews where people raved about it. I wouldn’t normally believe that a prison BL story could be anything but the characters getting raped over and over again. Except this is genuinely passionate. Sen learns to take the abuse that is dished out to him out of fear of violence or death, or worse, getting gang raped rather than raped by Sword Fish. And this is the one time Stockholm Syndrome will ever be believable, because with nothing better to do, after going through the motions of lovemaking again and again in order to spite each other, Sen and Sword Fish really do fall in love. And it is a violent, men-in-prison kind of love, with lots of jealousy, mistrust, people meddling on both sides, and bad stuff in general, like when Sword Fish keeps having people killed.

The prison setting isn’t realistic at all, but it doesn’t really have to be. I don’t think there are any prisons where someone like Sword Fish can have inmates killed again and again, or distribute drugs as freely and under the watchful eye of the warden. Also, I doubt there are very many prison wardens that put a mask on and rape people in solitary confinement. For some reason, these elements take me out of the story, perhaps because the setting is such a big part of what’s going on. It is the story. So it calls attention to itself when anything is slightly wrong.

I read both volumes at once. I’ll talk a little bit about the plot of the series with the next review, but here I’ll talk about Sen and Sword Fish. I do like the way both of them develop over the course of these two books. I also enjoyed the contrast between their lives in and out of prison. We see little outside the routine violence, but it’s fascinating when they reveal little bits of who they were before they were put away. Sen was raped by the husband of his lover, and Sword Fish has a wife and kid that he sees rarely. Both are also straight before they fall in love with each other, deciding that with their life sentences, what use was there to resist their feelings? As much as Sword Fish forced sex on Sen, he was most resistant to homosexual love, saying his abuse was a form of “payment” to keep the other guys off Sen, that it was over if he ever thought Sen was enjoying anything they did together, et cetera. And Sword Fish is the one that denies his feelings longer than Sen does. Sen accepts it, and though the transition to the two of them being a couple is full of drama and abuse and murder, there is no big emotional scene where there is a love confession with lots of denials and whatnot. Both just pick up on it themselves. Sen realizes his feelings before Sword Fish does, but he keeps quiet about it until he thinks Sword Fish is ready to hear it.

I’ll probably talk more about those two next time too, especially when I discuss the Warden and Norman, but for now, there’s a little bit of analysis for you. It is hard to read with all the intense violence and abuse, but there’s also quite a bit of addicting and genuine passion and romance written into the characters, and for that, it succeeds where too many other BL books fail. And what’s the point of the sex if the characters don’t love each other? I think it’s boring without plenty of convincing romance. Though… again, much of the romance in this series is cringe-inducing and makes me sick to my stomach. Seriously. This is probably one of the most graphic BL series published in English.

2 Responses to “Under Grand Hotel 1”

  1. […] artist basso – or she might be confronted with the brutally violent mess of broken taboos that is Under Grand Hotel. Many people who write about yaoi, such as Che Gilson in the “Fujoshi USA” column of Otaku USA, […]

  2. Cloud Says:

    I just read the whole manga but I interpreted it in a different way. I never got the feeling Sen let himself be raped by Sword to gain protection… The very first day they met Sword saved Sen’s life. And then in the shower room they had a realy passionate scene (even when Sen excused it as “cuting ties”, he was having fun himself and they where joking afterwards) and Sen was the one to french kiss Sword.
    I got the feeling they liked each other from the start. Even Sen said (in a later chapter) that he could protect himself and there is an other reason why he is with Sword.
    Further it was explained later that Sen has a weakness for forbidden affairs and that it gives him the thirll.
    I can’t see any “Stockholm Syndrome” or abuse – exept for the scene when Sword really raped him!

    I agree that the prison setting is unrealistic. Then again dealing drugs in prisons is REAL. Corrupt wardens are REAL. Just google “drugs” and “prison” and you will see. Maybe the reason why the warden raped Sen was unrealistic but rape of inmates by staff is a real problem! Even murder in prison is not uncommon… in contrast to your opinion SOME of these elements made the story more realistic for me!

    Also the ending is not THAT unrealistic. I was expecting the worst… but in comperison to a lot of other escape stories it’s acceptable.
    After all it was the FBI Sword made a deal with! Maybe in reality they would have released them in a less dramatic way… but do we know? The FBI is able to give people new names and new lifes.
    Sword made the deal with Walter and they made the whole thing up. I don’t know if it was arranged that they where only slightly injured or maybe they had worn bulletproof vest with fake-blood on it… because there was very view explained you can almost create your own ending.
    Or do you think “in reality the FBI would have never released murderers” – just open the newspaper and see how crooked this world is :(

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: