April 12, 2015
Kumiko Suekane – Viz – 2011 – 12+ volumes
Okay, this volume was much better. I’m not really feeling the whole Dolly plot (everything’s just a little too cryptic), but I think what’s happening is far more interesting than “high school with famous people, except that they’re famous people doesn’t really matter because they act like regular manga high school students.”
Mostly, this volume left off on a bit of a cliffhanger. Granted, it was one I anticipated, but now I’m sad it’s going to take some time to track down volume 3.
Mostly, “Almighty Dolly” fanaticism is sweeping the school, and some of the students are taking it creepily seriously. I can’t figure out if they genuinely believe (though I’m willing to bet Joan of Arc does), or if some are plants (they are), or… what.
Also, there’s an anti-clone organization, and someone who’s spying on the clones, and then there’s the president of the school, Rockswell. He’s kind of like Lory from Skip Beat, or Tamaki from Ouran High School Host Club, in that he’s just an eccentric, off-beat rich person. But he’s obviously spying the clones, and he seems sort of anti-clone. So I’m not sure where all of this is going.
Also unfortunate, there are a few too many characters, and so far, I don’t like any of them. The main character is a little weak for my tastes, and I thought it was weird he got swept up in clone religion even though he wasn’t a clone. I guess he wanted to empathize that badly, but it didn’t read quite right, especially when that became almost entirely what was going on with him this volume.
But I think my favorite so far is Clone Himiko. She actually hasn’t had very many lines, or much of a part at all. I just like that, somehow, they cloned Himiko. She’s been dead about 1,800 years, and they don’t even know where her court was. But somehow, they found her remains and cloned her.
Also, Rockswell is… very eccentric. Quote of the volume, on the benefits of adoption: “I mean, it’s a lot of work having a kid on your own, right? Once you decide you want one, you’ve got to have sex, and then you have to wait around till it’s born, and by then you might be over the whole thing. Besides, when they’re first born they’re like little rodents! This size [pointing to a 4-year-old] is way better!”
I’m not sold, but I need to read more volumes to make a decision. It’s interesting, at least.
December 19, 2014
Kumiko Suekane – Viz – 2010 – 12+ volumes
I read a random volume of this series, and was intrigued enough to go back to the beginning and start fresh. Or, at least, to buy the first couple volumes and sit on them for years. But I’m reading them now, which is the important part.
The premise is that the main character, Shiro Kamiya, goes to a high school filled with clones that his dad created. He has a crush on the recently-transferred-out Marie Curie, is friends with Napoleon, frenemies with Freud, and gets beat up by Mozart. So there’s that.
It inevitably reminds me of Clone High, which was only on for a second and I watched a couple episodes of. From what I recall, it’s a lot like Clone High with different historical figures. It’s kinda weird.
Anyway. The first chapter of Afterschool Charisma is rough, since it handles the subject matter rather awkwardly and unsubtly. It’s mostly a flashback to a tearful outburst from Marie Curie, who doesn’t want to be a physicist and only wants to make music. Shiro agrees with her, and intervenes with his dad on Marie’s behalf. She is transferred out, and all the various student reactions (Shiro has a crush! Her friend Florence Nightingale misses her!) are shown.
It was pretty awful. Then, in chapter two, we are shown the first successful clone grown to maturity, John F. Kennedy (he is very pretty in this manga). His first foray into public life is a speech he delivers about picking up where the original Kennedy left off. He is promptly assassinated.
I… wasn’t sure what to make of that, honestly. Is it brilliant? Accidental? In any case, it kept me reading.
Sadly, this first volume is mostly high school stuff. Shiro doesn’t fit in because he’s the only “normal” one. As such, he’s the outcast in a school full of strange outcasts. He has friends, blushes at girls, fights with Mozart, and all of it isn’t super-interesting yet. Towards the end of the volume, we start to get hints of a terrorist organization that doesn’t like the clone program and wants to kill them all.
Hmm. I have the second volume, and will probably keep reading. I’m a bit disappointed with the wasted premise so far, though. Maybe once it focuses more on the private lives of the clones, the story will get more interesting.
March 21, 2012
Kumiko Suekane – Viz – 2012 – 7+ volumes
You know, a series like this has to work hard to impress me. This may be entirely Clone High’s fault, but a premise about clones of historical figures from around the world is also just a little much for me. Especially since this volume has Adolf Hitler on the cover. I went into this prepared to hate it. I finished with a fair degree of admiration. That’s difficult to do.
This was a good volume to start with, too. There seems to have been some terrorist activity last time, and this entire volume is a flashback told by Kai, the leader of the terrorists. The terrorists were older clone versions of all the students at the school presently, and I have no idea what was going on there, but the flashback from Kai’s point of view is interesting.
Now, Kai isn’t anyone famous. He’s the only student not living in the shadow of the past. But during the course of the flashback, another clone Kai joins the classes with original Kai. There is no difference between the Kais. None. Nobody can tell the difference between the two, including Elizabeth, who appears to be a sort-of girlfriend. The parts where it’s unclear are quite chilling, because in the end, the conclusion that’s reached is that it really doesn’t matter. And in the context of the story… it doesn’t. Even original Kai stops caring that he’s not an individual anymore.
I loved that it took the usual manga themes of being yourself and being an individual and turned it on its head. Because it doesn’t matter if Kai is himself or not, there’s another Kai just like him, down to a personality that’s so close that not even his closest friends can tell the difference.
I assume the series has been working with these themes since the first volume, though. There are some hints about how much the clones are or are not trying to be like their originals, and how it may or may not affect their lives, but I suspect that the story may have already dealt with some of this in earlier volumes. I was worried initially, when one of the first scenes in the flashback is Freud oogling girls in the swimming pool and getting into a fight with Jung, who’s more sexually repressed, and the whole thing ends with Florence Nightingale being called on for first aid. But it gets more tasteful from there. Should Elizabeth try hard to be like the original Elizabeth, or does it ultimately not matter, especially since she isn’t allowed to leave the school? What happens to the clones when they leave, and what is the upcoming Festival about? This is particularly relevant to the Hitler clone, of course, who tries hard to separate himself from the original. But that’s not really relevant here. I suspect it will be more so in the next volume, though.
While I still find the premise inherently ridiculous, I do like that the plot explores the most interesting parts of it. I’m curious to see what the early volumes are like, so I’ll probably be picking those up in the future, but I’m more interested to see what this Kai business is. Why are the Kai clones so terrifying?
And, most interesting, is the one telling the story that Kai? I… I don’t think he is.
This was a review copy provided by Viz.